|
 |
The Judge's Box |
|
|
|
Question: It seems from looking at many
events and contests that bands who have the unfortunate luck of
going first seem to be at a distinct disadvantage. History seems to
support this assumption. How do you evaluate the “first” band to go
without holding scores? |
|
|
|
|
|
Answer:
While I can’t speak for all judges, I’ve always
approached each show with an attitude of “who is going to show up
and want to win today?” If the first band out of the gate lays down
a great performance that is lighting up the crowd and meeting all
the criteria, I most definitely want to reward them for their
efforts. After scanning over the back of the sheet, I will assign
their score based on the criteria, and ONLY based on the criteria.
I don’t know nor do I really care what they received last week, or
even last year. I’m judging the show for that day. That
band then sets the standard for the rest of that class or contest.
Everyone else would need to meet or exceed that same standard. If
they don’t, then they would be ranked lower in my caption. Now,
here is where this can sometimes cause a fluctuation in numbers. If
Band #1 out of a 30 band show has a great show, let’s say I score
them at an 85 in my caption (again based on the criteria). My
dilemma now is that I potentially have another 29 bands that may
need to fit into my remaining 15 points if indeed they are all
better than Band #1. This may cause a compression in scores due to
the spread from band to band (I’ll be using tenths of a point vs.
whole points). Should I score Band #1 lower and “leave room” for
the other 29 bands? No – my number for Band #1 wouldn’t then match
the tape commentary I’ve given them nor correctly reflect their
level of achievement. Numbers management is one of the hardest
things to master in judging. Just a few weeks ago, I judged a show
where the first two bands that appeared in an 8-band class ended up
finishing first and second. None of us on the panel had seen them
before, but the performances that they gave warranted the numbers
that they received. |
|
|
|
This web site is provided as a public service
for
the Staff, Students, Alumni, Parents and Fans of
Kentucky School Bands. |
|